From hand-breaded fried chicken and Captain Smith's seafood platter to broiled salmon, jumbo shrimp, family packs, and everything in between.
4 cheese sticks, 4 chicken wings, french fries, and 4 chicken tenders.
1 dozen wings served with celery sticks and bleu cheese or ranch.
8 chilled jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce.
Crispy blooming onion, your choice of spicy or plain.
Crispy shrimp tossed in zesty buffalo sauce.
6 pieces of golden, melty mozzarella sticks with marinara.
Crispy battered dill pickle chips, served with ranch.
Breaded jalapeño slices with a kick.
Rich, creamy New England-style clam chowder, made fresh.
Crisp greens, tomatoes, cheese, croutons, bacon bits & onions.
Tossed salad topped with grilled chicken strips.
Tossed salad topped with boiled shrimp.
Tossed salad topped with salmon chunks.
Topped with salmon chunks, grilled chicken strips & boiled shrimp.
Hand-breaded, golden, unforgettable. Served with hushpuppies, slaw, and your choice of side.
Hand-breaded crispy tenders. Family-friendly classic.
Dipped in buffalo sauce, served with celery sticks and ranch.
Bite-size crispy fried chicken pieces.
6 piece wing plate with hushpuppies, slaw, and side.
Hand-breaded wings with hushpuppies, slaw, and your choice of side.
Choice of white or dark meat. Comes with any 2 sides and hushpuppies.
Mixed chicken. All white or all dark available with $1 upcharge. Comes with any 2 sides and hushpuppies.
All chicken bags come with hushpuppies.
Hand-breaded catfish filet, lightly seasoned and fried golden.
Crispy flounder filet, light and flaky inside.
4 piece baby flounder plate, perfectly crispy.
Mild, flaky tilapia hand-breaded and fried.
2 piece plate of crispy white fish, mild and flaky.
2 piece fillet of trout, hand-breaded and crispy.
A heap of crispy baby shrimp, family favorite.
10 piece jumbo shrimp plate, hand-breaded and crispy.
Whole croaker fried to crispy perfection. A Southern coast classic.
10 piece oyster plate, lightly breaded and golden.
10 piece sea scallop plate, sweet and tender.
Bold cajun seasoning. ($1 up-charge for cajun batter)
Crispy fried clam strips.
House-made stuffed deviled crab, fried golden.
Served hot or cold.
Served hot or cold.
The best of both worlds — crispy buffalo tenders with cajun-spiced catfish.
Pick any 2 different fried items. Perfect when you can't decide.
Pick any 3 different fried items for the ultimate combo.
Go big — 4 different fried items, one massive platter.
Two generous filets broiled in butter and special seasoning. Served with salad, hushpuppies, and a side.
3 piece broiled tilapia with butter and seasoning.
3 piece broiled catfish filet, light and flaky.
3 piece broiled flounder filet, classic Mayflower preparation.
4 piece broiled white fish in butter and seasonings.
3 piece broiled trout filet, light and buttery.
14 piece jumbo shrimp broiled to perfection.
A heap of broiled baby shrimp.
14 piece sea scallops broiled in butter.
Pick any 2 different broiled seafood items from the list above.
Pick any 3 different broiled seafood items from the list above.
Hand-cut USDA ribeye, grilled to your preferred temperature.
2 boneless grilled chicken breasts with tossed salad and your choice of sides.
2 grilled chicken breasts glazed with teriyaki sauce.
Fried or grilled — your choice. Served with salad and 1 side, or choose 2 side items.
Generous hamburger steak smothered with onions and gravy.
3 made-from-scratch crab cakes, packed with jumbo lump crab meat, served with tossed salad and your choice of sides.
Flounder, baby shrimp, oysters, scallops & stuffed deviled crab. (No Substitutions)
Flounder, jumbo shrimp, oysters, scallops, Alaskan white fish and stuffed deviled crab. (No Substitutions)
Flounder, baby shrimp, trout, scallops & stuffed deviled crab — broiled.
Flounder, Alaskan white fish, baby shrimp, jumbo shrimp, scallops & deviled crab — broiled.
Fried baby shrimp, 4 fried jumbo shrimp, hot/cold boiled baby shrimp. (No Substitutions)
3 clusters of fresh, steamed crab legs.
14 piece jumbo shrimp, steamed and served in the shell.
Classic creamy alfredo sauce over fettucini pasta.
Our creamy fettucini topped with grilled chicken strips.
Creamy alfredo with sautéed shrimp.
Hearty spaghetti with house marinara.
Oven-baked spaghetti with melted cheese on top.
Fried or grilled chicken topped with marinara and melted mozzarella.
House-made tuna salad on a fresh bun.
Crispy fried fish filet on a bun with all the fixings.
Your choice of grilled or fried chicken breast on a bun.
Fried or grilled chicken tossed in buffalo sauce.
12 Pieces · Feeds 6 People. Includes fries or baked potato, hushpuppies & slaw.
24 Pieces · Feeds 6 People. Includes fries or baked potato, hushpuppies & slaw.
Generous Portion · Feeds 6 People. Includes fries or baked potato, hushpuppies & slaw.
Classic Southern banana pudding made fresh.
Rich red velvet cheesecake.
A decadent peanut and chocolate dessert.
Our fish is machine fillet — some small bones may be found on occasion. Shells or pearls may be found in oysters on occasion.
Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, pork, seafood or shellfish may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
Senior citizens (age 55+) receive 10% off all items, excluding senior plates, children's plates, daily specials, crab legs, side orders and beverages.
All to-go orders are $0.25 extra. 15% gratuity added to parties of 8 or more. Mayflower is takeout only — we do not offer delivery.
Call ahead, or come on in. We'll have a table waiting.